Skip to main content

Insurance agents who are selling property and casualty policies to their clients realize the potential in these sales to ultimately increase their commissions. If you want to land more property and casualty (P&C) insurance sales, communication is key. After all, the business is rooted in pricey assets, sentimental items, and some of the most cherished valuables your clients will ever hold. By delivering the right emails to your clients about these high-value items, you can boost your insurance sales.

Wondering how to tailor emails to generate more leads and secure more property and casualty insurance sales? Follow these simple email marketing tactics for insurance agents to open up communication, build deeper relationships, and spark more sales.

Why Is Email Marketing Important for P&C Insurance Sales Agents?

Wondering why email marketing is becoming such a red-hot sales tool in P&C insurance? 

First, it’s a way to dig up new leads and stay connected with customers. Equally important, email marketing can carry those leads down your sales funnel in a hurry, and it can quickly convert cold leads into sales. 

For property and casualty insurance agents like you, email marketing can also help tap into a growing market. According to the Radicati Group, the number of email users recently jumped past 2.8 billion worldwide. With email marketing, you can tap into this growing pool of clients, spot those cross-sale opportunities that pay the bills, and secure long-term business. 

As a whole, when done right, email marketing has the power to help insurance agents craft deeper relationships and electrify sales.

Email Marketing Best Practices for Elevating P&C Insurance Sales

If you want to earn a steady income off of your potential and existing property and casualty insurance sales, it takes stellar relationship-building efforts. You need to keep up with clients and secure commissions from renewable policies. At the same time, you need to nurture those new leads, encourage referral business, and identify cross-selling opportunities

With a few strategies in place, email marketing can help insurance agents elevate their sales game on all levels. Here’s how to use P&C insurance email marketing to boost your property and casualty insurance sales:

Educate Customers

Most clients don’t have a firm grasp on the particulars of property and casualty benefits, restrictions, and policies. In fact, most clients don’t even have a general understanding of what P&C insurance covers. According to a 2020 Policygenius study, more than 80 percent of homeowners don’t understand that earthquakes aren’t covered by a standard policy. The same survey found nearly half of homeowners don’t fully understand how to calculate their home insurance coverage accurately.

With email marketing, you can help teach clients about property and casualty insurance. As they start to understand the benefits, the qualifications, and other finer points of policies, they’ll feel more and more confident in their choices. 

That confidence can embolden them to buy the products that will benefit them the most. 

All the while, clients who pick up quality education will reward you with loyalty. After all, the learning process can build trust between you and your client. In turn, clients and prospects will be more likely to pass your name on to friends and neighbors. 

Wondering how insurance agents can use email marketing to educate clients?

Start by describing the advantages of and differences between multiple plans. The more you’re able to lay out a visual, side-by-side comparison of quotes, the easier it will be for your clients to see what policies fit their needs most. Be sure to organize multiple options for clients and lay them out in a clean way that makes sense. 

Focus Your Messages

Remember, property and casualty insurance deals with sensitive subjects for many clients. You’re caring for valuable assets that your clients have deep connections with. That’s why your email marketing messages should provide peace of mind and connect on a deep level. Here are a few tips that can help you strike the right chord with your clients and prospects:

  • Be authentic: Your contacts want to know they’re communicating with a human who cares about their situation. That’s why it’s important to cut out any overly technical language or robotic phrases. 
  • Be sensitive: In property and casualty insurance, you may be working with items that clients feel are irreplaceable. Be sensitive to their concerns. Reassure them that they’ll be covered during emergencies. The more comfortable you make them feel, the more receptive they’ll be to your messages. 

Simplify Your Role

As an insurance agent, you have a full plate. You may be wondering, “Who has time for email marketing?” This is where technology takes property and casualty insurance sales to the next level. There are two up-front ways automation simplifies your role:

  • Email automation: With email automation, property and casualty insurance software keeps you in contact with your leads and clients. It can also help you pass on personalized messages that show you care. For instance, you can schedule emails to land in leads’ inboxes on birthdays, on holidays, and during other special events. Ultimately, insurance software can do the heavy lifting when it comes to sending emails. That frees you up to spend more time closing those deals that will turn into revenue.
  • CRM automation: As you well know, keeping track of contacts and searching for new cross-sell opportunities is a major part of boosting your property and casualty insurance commissions. And if you’re handling those tasks manually, it can eat into your day. End-to-end CRMs organize contacts for you, automate workflows, and make it easier to act on cross-sell opportunities. Essentially, this technology lays customers’ information right in front of you so you can see every contact’s insurance story, their needs, and additional sales opportunities. 

Build Relationships

In the property and casualty insurance world, building meaningful relationships is a must. Your clients are protecting some of their most valuable assets. That’s why your emails need to be personalized.


The key is keeping contact information organized. By keeping notes, family circumstances, personal details, and other information in a single place, you’ll have everything you need to craft messages that show you care.

Keep Up on Personal Events

If you’re slow to respond or lose touch with leads, they can easily fall through the cracks and move on to a new provider. That’s why keeping up on personal events is such an asset in insurance email marketing. 

Remember to check in on birthdays, on holidays, and during other events. This will show you care and keep your services fresh in your prospects’ minds. 

Also, be sure to ask for referrals. When it comes to property and casualty insurance, it’s tough to make a living by simply relying on unsolicited referrals. By encouraging leads to pass your information on, you can multiply business quickly and reap the commissions from renewed policies.

Stay Up to Date on the Latest in Insurance Technology


Mastering email marketing has the potential to help you accelerate your property and casualty insurance sales, generate more leads, and build deeper relationships. And we have more tips for using insurance technology to increase sales. 

Want to stay up to date on the latest insurance technology trends and grab insider tricks for boosting insurance sales? Subscribe to our blog today and stay ahead of the competition.


White Paper – The Complete Guide to Successful Cross-Selling

Stay Connected

Subscribe to our blog for the latest articles on trends and tips for insurance professionals.